Alabama Animal Advocates

Animal Census Reports in Alabama

Imagine of woman sitting at a desk examining data.

Monthly Animal Shelter Reports are Required

Impoundment facilities and shelters in Alabama are required to report monthly on animal intakes, outcomes, and other data, per the Animal Census Reporting Act of 2015, Alabama Code § 3-10-1 et seq. The Animal Census Reporting Act is the only shelter accountability measure required by the State of Alabama.

The specific information to be included is delineated in § 3-10-3:

Intake is a tally of pets taken in by the shelter.

Outcomes represent Intaked pets who have left the shelter. Live Outcomes include:

Fatal Outcomes include:

The Act also requires number of animals sterilized after arrival, and costs incurred by the facility for “housing, maintenance, feeding, medications, transfer, euthanasia, and other expenses related to the care of the animals and their disposition, excluding salary and benefits paid to employees.”

Each report is due 30 days from the end of the month and must be maintained for at least three years, per § 3-10-4.

Live Release Rate

Live Release Rate (LRR) is the percentage of pets who left the shelter alive. This rate is calculated by dividing Live Outcomes by Total Outcomes.

Why is the Live Release Rate important? The LRR is a tool that is an indicator of progress. The rate also shows trends to help a shelter determine if there are areas where improvement is needed. Examples include low return to owner rates and putting too much reliance on rescue groups to save animals while not engaging with the public being served to get animals adopted.

Does the Live Release Rate tell us if all the healthy and treatable animals are saved? The LRR does not tell us if all healthy and treatable animals are saved. For shelters with very high live release rates (in the mid-to-high 90s range), it is reasonable to believe that the animals euthanized were suffering, were irremediably ill or were dogs that were genuinely aggressive to people.

Are there animals that should not be included in calculating the Live Release Rate? Yes. The shelter should only include animals for which there was an intake as opposed to animals for which some type of service was provided. Shelters should not include cats from public TNR programs, movement of animals within an organization or animals for which intake prevention support was provided. These are animals for which services were provided but that were not part of the shelter intakes and outcomes. Data should be maintained for community services that are provided but should be kept separate from the shelter intake and outcome data.

How can we determine if the lives of all healthy and treatable animals were saved? We can determine the reasons why animals’ lives ended by using a public records request to seek monthly euthanasia reports that list the reasons for each death. This information is only as good as the record keeping and honest reporting of the information.

What is the origin of the reference to a Live Release Rate of 90%? There was a time almost two decades ago when a LRR above 90% was considered an indicator of progress. This was based on a very limited data set that existed at the time. The people who first referred to the 90% mark (Nathan and Jennifer Winograd) have called this their “Frankenstein’s Monster” because it has since been used not as a tool, but as a goal, and has caused bad actors to mislead the public. Due to improvements in veterinary medicine and development of progressive animal shelter programs, some shelters save as many as 98% of the animals.

How has the 90% Live Release Rate been misused? Some shelters have become so focused on this rate that they have refused to provide required services to preserve the rate. Other shelters have misled the public about the number of animals who died to make their rates look better than they are, essentially refusing to count some animals. Still other shelters have misled the public about the reasons why animals’ lives were ended to gain or keep public favor.

Why Data Matters

The State of Shelter Reporting in Alabama

Who is responsible for shelter operation? Government impoundment facilities are the responsibility of counties and cities, who either run them directly or contract their operation to a third party. Public charity shelters are the responsibility of their governing boards.

Responsible parties should be reviewing reports, but are they? Shelter directors and staff and their their supervisory governments and boards have a direct interest and responsibility to regular reviewing Census Reports. Many or most do not. We have found that many officials and some shelter directors have not even heard of the Census Reporting Act and are neither collecting nor reviewing data.

Claims about Alabama shelter data are not reliable. We frequently see claims such as how many animals die in Alabama shelters each year or how Alabama shelters compare to other states. Such claims are broad estimates, at best. There simply is not data to support them. There is no agency in Alabama that oversees animal shelters or that collects data. Unlike other states, the Alabama Dept. of Agriculture exercises no direct oversight over companion animals, animal shelters or rescue groups.

Transparency is lacking. A handful of Alabama shelters proactively share their Census Reports. They are included in the Alabama shelter data linked below. We support the open sharing of full Census Reports (including not only positive outcomes, but also fatalities) on websites and on social media.For every other pound and shelter, Census Reports can be requested via a public records request. The data we share, for example, has required many, many hours of requests and followup, and still represents only a small percentage of public facilities in the state.

A few shelters refuse to comply with state law. Some shelters do not comply with the Animal Census Reporting Act and/or publish manipulated or irreconcilable data. Although noncompliance is a violation of Alabama law, individuals cannot insist on compliance because the law was amended during the legislative process to remove any private right of action. The government officials that could insist on compliance have, in our experience, chosen not to.

Alabama Animal Shelter Data

This list includes data that is shared publicly or that has been provided in response to our requests. To submit data, email us.

How to Request Animal Shelter Data in Alabama

See the guide at Animal Census Requests.